Having the Old shop menu with the guides would be way better.
Make the guides small and a separate button to bring up so it doenst interfere with every1 who doesn't want it.
And make it so you can create your own guides within HoN so its easy and you can refer to how you like to play the specific hero.
I like both shops. One change that is needed is to allow a player to create our or guides in-game (new shop) and modify the list of recommended items (old shop). Also, we need an interface option where we can choose between the new and old shop (actually we can do it by console only).
Nobody with more then 100-150 games need a guide to a hero.
If somebody never played a hero after 150 games, you know how the hero works, just from the experience you made in those 150 games before, by watching other people playing it
New players can go the the forum=> training ground. It's even said in the tutorial, lulz
tl,dr. didn't vote cause ingame guides sucks