I would like this thread to be a reminder or perhaps for someone who doesn't know it. I tried to search for this in some "user" guide created here and I rarely see this.
Always target the Melee barrack first when you attack the ennemy base (if possible...)
- Lower HP regen than Range barrack = faster to kill
- If you kill melee rax, it gives you better creeps (like 4, 5 better melee creep) vs Range barrack that only gives 1 range creep (or 2?)
- Range barrack have a high HP regen, this mean that it will take longer to kill = this mean the other team have more time to come and kill you.
The only time I would target the range barrack first is for some reason his remaining HP is very low. Then some quick hits will kill it fast. But if you face the 2 rax full HP, GO melee first.
Simply create a practice game and look at the HP regen of Range barrack vs Melee. Because practicly each game I play I need to say that in team chat, I decided to write a post...
Am I right about this? or not.
Last edited by Etdashou; 09-24-2009 at 12:23 PM. Reason: Changed to gameplay
Sometimes your creeps will stick to the ranged barracks and it's faster to focus it than to only use heroes on the melee barracks. But yes, melee barracks has higher payoff.
I ALWAYS focus melee barracks if team is with, or creeps aren't doing any damage to either rax for whatever reason, but if I have a bunch of creeps focusing the Ranged Barracks and we can take it down together (or do 1/2 damage to both), it's obviously better to focus whatever one the creeps are stuck on.
Yep, I agree with the creep! Logical anyway. But I would say (for most of the games I played..) that most of the time their is like 1 or 2 melee and one range left. If it is the case, and those creeps target Range, I think it is still better to go like 3 heroes on melee..
But if their is like 10 creeps on range... go for it.
Ranged Rax has 5 armour, Melee Rax has 15. If you need to get out quickly, but have time for one Rax, take the Ranged. If you have a bit more time, definitely take the Melee first.
Well.... I should have done that before.
I made a practice game, and created 3 heroes lvl 16 each with no gear really (LEgionaire, MAgebane, Moon Queen). And I spawned a melee barrack then a range barrack. I had a stopwatch to look at the time to kill each one individually. (it was spawned in the middle of the forest with no creep attacking but 3 heroes lvl 16)
Melee rax: 18s
Im a fool to believe that melee is faster.
Conclusion: If possible and you have time to, attack melee as it gives you a better advantage in-game.
However if you are short on time and want to try to do a rax kill, depending on your current creep attack, it may be faster on Range (however be careful that if you cant destroy the range, it will regen FAST).
Well.. there may be 365 other reasons to focus on one than the other, but it may help people to know the actual killing time from 3 normal heroes (with no gear).
More tests could be done.
afaik the two raxes have the same 2.5 static HP regen.
Melee Rax has 2850 effective HP, Ranged Rax has 1950.
I think Hero Damage in DotA deals 50% to Fortified Armor (buildings), I don't remember if that's the case within HoN.
dreamex, range barracks defuinitely have about 20 or so hp regen per second.
I wonder why, can't recall they ever had different reg in DotA?
And I never really though much about this, but:
Couldn't it be useful to only have that 1/2 buffed ranged creeps (instead of 4/5 melee ones) that push towards the enemy base slower, which will mean that if they reach the enemy base there will be far more creeps and especially ballistas/catapults?
Your creeps focus fire the ranged first... So If you rax the ranged first you have a better chance to kill the melee
Also Ranged barracks is where the damage is, so if you have upgraded archers/warlocks and you push another lane and they forget about the lane you raxed... Then they will be in trouble on more then 1 front [ If you get kicked out before you kill the melee ]
So the more the raxed lane gets pushed thats 1 / 2 people that have to keep defending it so thats 1 / 2 people not in a team fight and it can make a huge difference
I Win Games.
and what about the shrines? (I think thats the name).. what do they do? i've always wondered..
Ancients of Wind(?) in Dota have higher regen rates which corresponds to the ranged barracks having higher regen. I think shrines are supposed to replace ziggs/moon wells which don't really do anything in Dota except distract creep fire and they posses no regen.
Shrines give you a bit of gold if you last hit them, if I recall correctly, and otherwise just distract creeps.
^ Half a hero kill bounty is hardly "a bit of gold". But they do distract creeps.
Agreeing with OP 100%, FF the melee rax for the advantage in pushing down the lane.