Sherlock Holmes

[TreeHorse]

ITT: The movie would have been much better if Jude Law had played Sherlock Holmes, and RDjr Watson.

Thoughts?

[ellR]

nah, i dont think RDjr would play watson any good

besides, it was a GREAT movie =)

[TreeHorse]

Don't get me wrong, I agree it was awesome.

I just feel like Holmes should have been the tall dashing one and Watson the short neurotic comedic one.

[MagicCake]

I liked the movie, it fit well with the modern day style of movies but still had some Holmes like aspect to it.

I wanted to take my girlfriend to see it but she can't handle hanging scenes and this movie has two of them so... ja >.>

[Tyrando]

i think RDjr did a great job of Sherlock tbh.

[SAILORmars]

I loved the movie, RDjr is a great action, one of my favourites in fact, and he sure did a good job of this movie. And i do disagree, he fitted Holmes well.

[NrFive]

Really liked the movie, not RDjr at his best, but still very good :)

my full opinion on my site (see sig)

And looking at how Guy Ritchie wanted to portray both Sherlock and Watson, its better to have Robert as Sherlock and Jude as Watson.

[SideKick1]

keep your spam to training grounds plz

[TreeHorse]

keep your spam to training grounds plz

:blac:

[SideKick1]

u mad?

[TreeHorse]

u mad?

yes ;/

[Sagat]

And we go a bit more ontopic from now on
<3

[TreeHorse]

I'd just close it if I were you, I think I'm the only one who feels this way :)

[TomKat]

I enjoyed the bit when they got from the underground at Westminster to the top of Tower Bridge in under 5 minutes.

Although I was smug+++ when I realised that stupid snake thing was the Thames before they revealed it.

Bring a snobbish Londoner is brilliant.

[Altazor]

I solved the case at the opening title

BTW: what a entertaining movie, loved it!

[Darkstrand]

robert downy jr sucks dick at acting t-down

[kippetje]

I thought it was a great movie, and I think the main role fits RDjr more, I'm sorry but I just like his acting. He's funny :)

[Narfle]

William Dafoe should have played Holmes

and then it should have had an entirely different script

and had been about aliens